“The youth are angry, heaven and earth are weeping… How did our land become a sea of blood? How did the path home become a path of no return?” <a href="https://hongkongfp.com/2019/04/09/apple-music-china-removes-jacky-cheung-song-reference-tiananmen-massacre/" target="_blank"><ins>The Path of Man, by Jacky Cheung</ins></a>

Two years ago, Apple was removing a song by Hong Kong singer Jacky Cheung from its Chinese streaming service, along with the songs of other Hong Kong singers (Anthony Wong and Denise Ho).

Since 2019, thousands of apps have disappeared from Apple’s App Store in China. As described by the New York Times (link on the name NYT to their investigation), “Apple has created an internal bureaucracy that rejects or removes apps the company believes could run afoul of Chinese rules. Apple trains its app reviewers and uses special software to inspect apps for any mention of topics Apple has deemed off limits in China, including Tiananmen Square, the Chinese spiritual movement Falun Gong, the Dalai Lama, and independence for Tibet and Taiwan.”

Apple regularly claims it removes apps in China to comply with local laws, but, to date, the firm never substantiated those claims.

<img src="https://imagedelivery.net/NHMgb1rcyLEYLdoYfPVw7Q/cf8807a3-d0d7-4170-d14c-1727671e2f00/public" alt="undefined" style="height: auto;width: 100%"/>

#TiananmenSquareMassacre

On December 22, 2022 AppleCensorship releases two reports simultaneously, both highlighting Apple’s censorship of its App Stores and the company’s many compromises with authoritarian regimes.

The first report focuses on how Apple censors in Hong Kong.  As human rights and fundamental freedoms in the territory shrink, including digital rights, Apple is reluctant to take any commitment to uphold its users rights to access information freely and express their views online. The second report looks at Apple’s presence in Russia up until the start of the war in Ukraine in February 2022 and highlights the issues posed by Apple’s lack of transparency surrounding its App Store policies, including compliance with international sanctions.

Both reports highlight how far Apple is willing to go to safeguard its relationship with authoritarian regimes and maintain access to those markets.

“In the name of profit, Apple censors millions of users from all aspects of society: from activists and political figures to members of vulnerable minorities such as the LGBTQ+ community in Russia or religious and ethnic minorities in China,” said Benjamin Ismail, Director of the AppleCensorship project.&nbsp;

“<a href="https://applecensorship.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/AppleCensorship_Report_United-Apple-c.pdf" target="_self">United Apple: Apple’s censorship and compromises in Russia</a>“&nbsp;
<div style="text-align:left;"><img src="https://imagedelivery.net/NHMgb1rcyLEYLdoYfPVw7Q/d33c9583-357f-4f72-a338-11616e05ed00/public" alt="undefined" style="height: auto;width: 30%"/></div>
In AppleCensorship’s report focusing on Russia, entitled “United Apple” in reference to Russian president Vladimir Putin’s party “United Russia”, the organization has taken a deeper look at Russia’s App Store, where many LGBTQ+ related apps are blocked.

While many “Shopping”, “Finance” and “Business” apps were removed from the Russian App Store shortly after the start of the war in Ukraine, AppleCensorship’s research has revealed much more worrying trends:

●          Patterns of app removals from Russia’s App Store detected by the App Store Monitor (ASM) suggest that specific groups of apps have been targeted by the Russian authorities and that a system of Apple-enforced targeted censorship is in place in Russia’s App Store.
●          LGBTQ+ related apps constitute the most prominent type of apps being unavailable in Russia’s App Store, with at least 25 apps currently unavailable, including some of the most popular LGBTQ+ apps in the world.
●          More than 30 VPN and private browsing apps have been taken down since the start of the war in Ukraine, while the Russian authorities were announcing that “measures were being taken to limit access to VPN services that violate Russian law”.
●          Although Russia’s App Store does not reflect the present government-controlled media landscape, the list of unavailable news apps continues to grow as the App Store Monitor unveils new foreign media blocked or removed from Russia’s App Store.
●          Apple’s recent actions regarding several other apps operated by companies owned by Russian oligarchs who have been sanctioned, point towards contradictory behavior from Apple, and raise questions whether Apple’s opaque management of its App Store is compatible with the necessary scrutiny and respect for human rights principles and values that is required of private companies.

“Apple’s content curation policies represent a denial of the company’s stated principles and values and show a lack of respect for privacy and the protection of users’ rights. In Russia, Apple has enabled censorship of vulnerable communities while promoting apps that are used by the government for surveillance purposes,” added Ismail.&nbsp;


“<a href="https://applecensorship.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Apps-at-Risk_-Apples-Censorship-and-Compromises-in-Hong-Kong.pdf" target="_self">Apps at Risk: Apple’s censorship and compromises in Hong Kong</a>“

<div style="text-align:right;"><img src="https://imagedelivery.net/NHMgb1rcyLEYLdoYfPVw7Q/a18460bb-1068-4e90-3877-c2cdd018ea00/public" alt="undefined" style="height: auto;width: 30%"/></div>

<h2>&nbsp;“Apps at risk” investigates Apple’s censorship in Hong Kong’s App Store and assesses the compromises that Apple has made in the special administrative region.</h2>

Whether pressed by Hong Kong local administration or by the Chinese central government, on a number of occasions Apple has complied with demands to censor content deemed in violation of local laws or simply critical of Beijing.  

“Apps at risk” highlights threats to freedom of information that Apple’s predominance in Hong Kong poses. Some of the key findings included in the report include:

●          Hong Kongers’ reliance on mobile apps that are banned in China to communicate and access information make Apple a defect “kill switch” at the disposal of the Chinese censors.
●          While Hong Kong’s App Store remains relatively free compared to China’s App Store, a series of tests conducted in 2022 reveal that Hong Kong’s App Store is more restrictive than other App Stores considered “free”. The unavailability of apps in the Hong Kong App Store is higher than most of the 173 App Stores monitored by AppleCensorship.
●          In November 2022, a surprisingly high number of VPN and private browsing apps (more than 50) were found to be unavailable in Hong Kong’s App Store.
●          A number of apps related to media and information have been removed globally over the last two years, raising the possibility that self-censorship or censorship by Apple on behalf of the authorities are affecting apps’ availability globally.
●          Apple has not made any public commitment to uphold Hong Kongers’ fundamental rights to access information and express their opinion online. If the Chinese authorities were to increase digital censorship in the region, nobody knows how Apple will respond.

AppleCensorship has issued a set of recommendations for Apple, including demands that Apple declare publicly what measures it will take if Beijing increases its crackdown on digital freedoms and access to information in Hong Kong.

“Apple should make it very clear what actions it will, or will not take, to resist app takedown requests from Beijing or from Hong Kong’s government agencies,” said Ismail.

AppleCensorship has also made a similar demand regarding the company’s presence in Russia, asking that Apple “take measures to prevent any return to a normalization of its relationship with the Russian government.”

“As our two reports show, examples of Apple’s censorship abound. Apple’s temporary withdrawal from Russia following the start of the war in Ukraine, and Apple’s decision to move part of its production out of China, have not provided tangible evidence of any improvement of the situation in the App Store so far. For all we know, Apple is still willing to collaborate with repressive regimes.

We need to ensure that Apple will not contribute further to censorship and the erosion of democracy worldwide. This is why we will continue to monitor and highlight all cases of censorship, as well as to support any legislation that would reduce Apple’s dangerous hegemony over the peoples’ digital space”, Ismail concluded.


Read “<a href="https://applecensorship.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/AppleCensorship_Report_United-Apple-c.pdf" target="_self">United Apple: Apple’s censorship and compromises in Russia</a>“
Read “<a href="https://applecensorship.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Apps-at-Risk_-Apples-Censorship-and-Compromises-in-Hong-Kong.pdf" target="_self">Apps at Risk: Apple’s censorship and compromises in Hong Kong</a>“&nbsp;

The fundamental rights of millions are impacted when Apple does business with authoritarian regimes

“Taken Down” A Look into Apple’s Transparency Reports

在欧洲限制言论自由是专制者的胜利

Banned Apps in China are Apps at Risk in Hong Kong

Company Overview
We are a mission-driven organization committed to monitoring and combating app censorship on a global scale. We are in search of a dedicated and proficient Web Developer to lead the development and ongoing maintenance of three distinct projects: a new website for our Play Store Monitor (PSM), improvements to our existing App Store Monitor (ASM) website, applecensorship.com, and a completely new website that will host our Mobile App Censorship (MAC) monitor.
The Play Store Monitor, currently in development, aims to let users test app availability in over 140 countries where Google Play is operational. This initiative complements our existing ASM, which is already operational on applecensorship.com and offers similar functionalities for Apple’s App Store. The MAC monitor will be an integrated platform that combines data from both Apple and Google stores, offering users a comprehensive view of app availability across these major platforms.
 
If you are passionate about digital rights and possess the technical skills to contribute to our vision, we invite you to join our team. &nbsp;
Job Role
Responsibilities:
• Lead the development and ongoing maintenance of our new Play Store Monitor (PSM) website, adhering to the UX design and guidelines set forth by our design team.
• Collaborate with multidisciplinary teams to deliver a comprehensive suite of website functionalities, such as real-time app availability testing, archival of historical test data, and in-depth pages for specific countries, apps, detected changes, and vanished apps.
• Ensure the website's optimal performance, scalability, and reliability to deliver a seamless user experience.
• Provide actionable suggestions for UI/UX improvements based on user feedback and performance metrics. &nbsp;
 Requirements:
• Expertise in front-end technologies.
• Mastery of back-end technologies.
• Familiarity with database management systems.
• Solid understanding of API integrations for data retrieval and manipulation.
• Demonstrable experience in responsive web design and ensuring cross-browser compatibility.
• Exceptional problem-solving abilities and meticulous attention to detail.
• Capability to work autonomously, effectively managing multiple responsibilities. &nbsp;
Bonus Points:
• Previous experience in digital rights, advocacy, or human rights projects.
• Contributions to open-source development initiatives. &nbsp;
Benefits:
• Competitive compensation package.
• Work remotely.
• Engage in meaningful work as part of a team committed to social impact.
• Access to professional development opportunities. &nbsp;
How to Apply:
1. Review the existing AppleCensorship website and come prepared with suggestions for improvements, along with recommendations for the software tools that could facilitate these enhancements.
2. Submit a link to one website you have developed that you're particularly proud of and that is relevant to this role.
3. Email your resume and portfolio to benjamin@greatfire.org, using the subject line "Mobile App Censorship Web Developer Application – [Your Name]."
 
If you're a skilled web developer with a commitment to digital rights and a desire to drive meaningful change, we encourage you to apply. Join us in our global endeavor to combat mobile app censorship; we are excited to see how you can contribute to our mission. &nbsp;